Skip to main content
Buyer guide · ROAS

How to choose campaign software for better ROAS: the criteria checklist

Campaign software improves ROAS only indirectly: by showing which network and campaign returns the most per euro, by letting you shift budget quickly, and by getting the next campaign live sooner. Choose it with ten criteria, weighted: networks in one view, ROAS by network and campaign, acting on the numbers, campaign creation, pricing model, setup time, client separation, scheduled reports, data handling and stated limits. AdSpectera scores highest on this list for small teams and agencies on Google, Meta, Microsoft, Pinterest or Reddit Ads; a PPC optimiser scores higher for one network with a large budget, and an enterprise suite for teams with a media department.

By , founder and managing director of Adnova UG, the company behind AdSpecteraPublished Updated 7 min read

What software can and cannot do for ROAS

No dashboard raises ROAS by itself. What raises it is a decision made earlier: budget moved from the campaign at 1.9 to the one at 4.1, a wasted search term excluded, a promo campaign paused on time, the next campaign launched a week sooner. Software helps when it shortens the path from number to decision to action. Judge it on that, not on the number of charts.

  • Seeing: ROAS per network and campaign against your target, in one date range and one currency.
  • Deciding: a breakdown that shows which campaign drags a network down, and an answer in plain words when you ask.
  • Acting: pause, enable and change budgets from the same view, and create the next campaign without starting from a blank ad manager.

The ten criteria, weighted

Score every tool from 0 (no) to 3 (fully) on each row during its trial, multiply by the weight and add it up. The weights below suit a small team or agency on several networks; change them before you score. The same table is the template at the end of this guide.

The ten criteria for campaign software, with weights
CriterionWhat to checkWeight
Networks in one viewDoes it show every network we buy on with the same metric names, one date range and one currency?20
ROAS by network and campaignCan we see ROAS, CPA and revenue per network and per campaign against our own target, without exporting?15
Acting on the numbersCan we pause, enable and change budgets from the same table, with changes synced back to the platform?15
Campaign creationDoes it draft the next campaign (copy, imagery, budget) and create it paused, or do we start from a blank ad manager?10
Pricing modelIs it priced per month with public prices, or an annual contract? Are users unlimited?10
Setup timeCan we connect accounts by signing in and see the first view the same day?10
Client and brand separationCan every brand or client have its own workspace, members and roles?5
Reports that send themselvesCan a report be scheduled as PDF or Excel to a client or team on a fixed day?5
Data handlingWhere is the company based, is there a DPA, and does it only read what we grant via the platform's own sign-in?5
What it does not doDoes the vendor state its limits (networks missing, no automated bidding), so we are not surprised later?5

How the common tool categories score

Typical scores by tool category (0 to 3 per criterion, before weighting)
CriterionAdvertising workspace (AdSpectera)Data connector (Supermetrics, Funnel)Client reporting (Whatagraph, AgencyAnalytics)PPC optimiser (Optmyzr, Adalysis)Enterprise suite (Smartly, Skai)
Networks in one view32 (once built)21 (search-centred)3
ROAS by network and campaign32223
Acting on the numbers3003 (in Google Ads)3
Campaign creation3 (AI Studio, paused)0013
Pricing model3 (monthly, public, unlimited users)2 (public, per source)1 (annual)2 (by ad spend)0 (annual contract)
Setup time3 (same day)1 (build the report)220 (onboarding)
Client and brand separation31323
Reports that send themselves31312
Data handling3 (German company, OAuth)2222
What it does not do3 (stated on the site)2221

Weighted with the table above, the workspace category scores about 290 of 300, connectors about 135, client reporting about 160, PPC optimisers about 175 and enterprise suites about 215. Your weights will move these; the point is to make the trade-off explicit.

Run the evaluation in two weeks

  1. Week 1, day 1: start the trials of two tools from different categories. Connect the same two ad accounts to both.
  2. Day 2: compare yesterday's spend and conversions for one campaign with the ad platform. Discard any tool whose numbers differ.
  3. Day 3: score criteria 1, 2 and 6 (view, ROAS, setup). You already know them.
  4. Day 5: pause one campaign, change one budget, create one test campaign paused. Score criteria 3 and 4.
  5. Week 2: schedule a report, invite a colleague as Viewer, read the privacy policy and the limits page. Score 5, 7, 8, 9 and 10.
  6. Day 14: add up the weighted scores, then compute the yearly cost at your spend and user count. Pick the higher score unless the cost difference is more than the time it saves.
Score with the person who does the Monday report, not only the person who signs the invoice. The tool has to shorten their path.

Three mistakes that make ROAS worse

  • Treating platform ROAS as comparable without checking attribution. Meta counts view-through; Google does not by default. Compare trends per platform first.
  • Buying optimisation for a network you spend little on. Optimisers pay off above a spend threshold; below it, a clear view and faster decisions return more.
  • Letting software change budgets without a review. Automated rules that chase last week's ROAS over-fund the campaign that already saturated. Prefer tools that propose and let you approve.
Template

Scoring template: campaign software for better ROAS

Copy the rows into a sheet, add one column per tool, score 0 to 3 per row during the trial, multiply by the weight and add it up.

Scoring template: campaign software for better ROAS
CriterionWhat to checkWeight
Networks in one viewDoes it show every network we buy on with the same metric names, one date range and one currency?20
ROAS by network and campaignCan we see ROAS, CPA and revenue per network and per campaign against our own target, without exporting?15
Acting on the numbersCan we pause, enable and change budgets from the same table, with changes synced back to the platform?15
Campaign creationDoes it draft the next campaign (copy, imagery, budget) and create it paused, or do we start from a blank ad manager?10
Pricing modelIs it priced per month with public prices, or an annual contract? Are users unlimited?10
Setup timeCan we connect accounts by signing in and see the first view the same day?10
Client and brand separationCan every brand or client have its own workspace, members and roles?5
Reports that send themselvesCan a report be scheduled as PDF or Excel to a client or team on a fixed day?5
Data handlingWhere is the company based, is there a DPA, and does it only read what we grant via the platform's own sign-in?5
What it does not doDoes the vendor state its limits (networks missing, no automated bidding), so we are not surprised later?5

Sources, checked on by Saman Bahmani, founder: adspectera.com/pricing, supermetrics.com/pricing, whatagraph.com/pricing, agencyanalytics.com/pricing, optmyzr.com/pricing, adalysis.com/pricing, smartly.io homepage, skai.io/pricing. Prices and features change; check each vendor for the latest details. Facts are re-checked every quarter; next review February 2027.

Other product names are trademarks of their owners; AdSpectera is not affiliated with them.

See it with your own accounts14 days of everything. No credit card.Start free trialSee pricing
FAQ

Questions people ask before choosing.

How do I choose campaign management software?

Score candidates on ten weighted criteria during a trial: networks in one view, ROAS by network and campaign, acting on the numbers, campaign creation, pricing model, setup time, client separation, scheduled reports, data handling and stated limits. Pick the highest weighted score at a cost you can justify by the time it saves.

Does campaign software improve ROAS?

Indirectly. It shows which campaign returns most per euro, lets you move budget and pause waste faster, and gets the next campaign live sooner. The ROAS gain comes from those decisions; the software shortens the path to them.

What is a good ROAS?

It depends on margin. A shop with a 40% gross margin breaks even on ads at a ROAS of 2.5; many aim for 3 to 4. A B2B lead campaign is judged on cost per qualified lead instead. Set your own target in the tool and compare networks against it.

Should the software change my bids automatically?

For one network with a large budget, a PPC optimiser's rules can help. For most small teams, a tool that proposes changes and lets you approve them avoids the over-funding that automated rules produce. AdSpectera never changes budgets or bids on its own.

How long should the evaluation take?

Two weeks with two tools from different categories connected to the same ad accounts. Most trials (AdSpectera 14 days, Supermetrics 14, Adalysis 30) cover that.